MVRDV has presented a new report that offers 5 recommendations to Bay Area officials on the region’s plans for a resilient future at the Global Climate Action Summit in San Francisco yesterday. 

Titled Too Much + Too Little, the report was created by MVRDV as part of the NL Resilience Collective, a collaboration with Deltares, Goudappel Coffeng, and ONE architecture. 

The report's goal is to help officials in the United States appreciate the Dutch approach to water management and integral design - an approach that has developed over centuries of dealing with water in a country where around 26% of the land is below sea level. This expertise could be invaluable for the Bay Area, a heavily populated region that is at risk from sea level rise and the effects of natural disasters.

San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge. Image courtesy of Chris Leipelt

Selected from a pool of 51 entries, 10 leading design teams, including BIG + ONE + SHERWOOD, BionicTeam, Common Ground HASSELL+MVRDV, Permaculture + Social Equity (P+SET), Public Sediment, The All Bay Collective, The Field Operations Team, The Home Team Team UPLIFT, are competing to cope with climate change and bring innovative community-based solutions for the San Francisco Bay area, which aims to strengthen San Francisco region’s resilience against sea level rise, severe storms, flooding and earthquakes.

"The NL Resilience Collective is an initiative that shows the power of integrative thinking and collaboration between government, designers and engineers that the Netherlands is well-known for," said MVRDV principal and co-founder Nathalie de Vries. 

"This way of working is the reason that we can tackle complicated, large-scale spatial problems by creating solutions that are beneficial for society as a whole."

MVRDV and HASSELL+ proposed "Collect And Connect" toolbox to revitalise disused public spaces. Image © MVRDV and HASSELL+

The report builds on MVRDV’s experience of taking part in the recent Resilient By Design competition held for the Bay Area, which resulted in 9 winning projects for sites throughout the region that will create awareness and conversation among locals, and become important test cases for resilient design. 

However, MVRDV and the NL Resilience Collective believes that successful resilient design also requires an approach that is both comprehensive (treating the entire region as a single system) and holistic (incorporating water management and climate change strategies into other plans for the region’s development).

MVRDV and HASSELL+ toolkit. Image © MVRDV and HASSELL+

"What the Bay Area is missing is an overarching approach, one that spans from Napa Valley to San Jose," said Henk Ovink, the Dutch water ambassador and a former member of President Obama’s Hurricane Sandy Rebuilding Task Force. 

"Right now, the issue is addressed by communities, cities, counties and the state separately. The problem with water is that it doesn’t stop at any man-made border. My solution too easily becomes my neighbour’s problem."

The 5 key recommendations made in the report are:

1. Update long-term plans to include water management and climate adaptation, integrating resiliency proposals into existing plans for issues such as housing and transport. Dealing with these issues separately leads to suboptimal or even counterproductive strategies.

2. Install a Bay Area Resiliency Commissioner, whose role will be to develop an integrated resiliency plan, to facilitate open access to relevant information, and to stimulate regional stakeholders to take action.

3. Understand your system. You can’t manage or improve what you don’t know, so it’s important to invest in data collection and monitoring systems for components of the region’s existing water system such as groundwater levels, surface water quality, and discharge and pumping locations.

4. Develop a set of design principles for local communities across the bay, collectively creating integrated design strategies that demonstrate how water infiltration, green spaces, active transportation, and liveable neighbourhoods can be tied together. Empowering communities with the knowledge and tools to act is crucial, and showing them how climate change already affects daily life can help to introduce a sense of urgency.

5. Start both big and small, to tackle the Bay Area’s huge resiliency challenges from the bottom-up and the top-down simultaneously. To bridge the gap between these two approaches, a knowledge centre should be developed to enable the collection and sharing of information between the government, the public, academics, and the private sector.

MVRDV and HASSELL+ toolkit. Image © MVRDV and HASSELL+

The Global Climate Action Summit aims to provide a launchpad to new initiatives that combat climate change and its effects, and to celebrate the achievements already made in this area by states, regions, cities, companies, investors, and citizens. 

MVRDV director Nathalie de Vries attended the summit with Senior Project Leader Kristina Knauf as part of a Dutch delegation that included 50 companies working in sectors such as energy, infrastructure, transport, manufacturing, and research.

Too Much + Too Little hopes to provide the impetus to adapt  the existing approach, and unite the Bay Area with a resiliency strategy that is more collaborative, more holistic, and—most importantly to the many Bay Area residents who are at risk—more successful.

Top image: MVRDV and HASSELL+ proposal for resiliency. 

> via MVRDV